⬇️ Prefer to listen instead? ⬇️
- A study shows dopamine changes the emotional value of memories when we recall them.
- Mice stopped liking a cue they used to like after remembering it when feeling bad.
- Turning on dopamine neurons made memories worse; turning them off stopped this from happening.
- Computer models correctly predicted how dopamine changes memory and behavior.
- These findings could change how we treat addiction, PTSD, and behavior problems.
Introduction
We often think of dopamine as the “feel-good” brain chemical linked to pleasure, motivation, and rewards. But new brain research changes this simple idea. It turns out dopamine also helps change the emotional feeling of memories after they form. Recent research in Communications Biology shows that dopamine not only helps us learn what’s rewarding, but it can also make those same memories less appealing if we recall them when we feel bad. This discovery is important for understanding learning, emotional memory, addiction, and treatments. It suggests we might need to rethink how reward learning and memory work.
The Old Idea: Reward Prediction Error
For many years, brain science has focused on an idea where dopamine’s main job is to signal a “reward prediction error” (RPE). This means dopamine neurons fire more when a reward is better than expected, and less when it’s worse. Basically, the dopamine system is like a feedback system that adjusts behavior based on whether things are better or worse than we thought they would be.
This idea fits with what we see in people and animals. If you eat a new food and it’s surprisingly good, your brain releases dopamine to help you remember it and want it again. If it’s disappointing, dopamine levels drop, making you less likely to want it again. It’s like a brain conditioning process that helps us make better choices in the future based on what we experience now.
This idea has helped explain many things about learning and motivation, but it also has limits. It assumes that once we form a memory, especially one about a reward, it stays pretty much the same until new reward experiences change it. But memories in real life aren’t that fixed. How we feel about past events can change a lot over time, especially if our mental, emotional, or physical state changes.
Dopamine and Memory: A New Look at Reward Learning
The new study adds an interesting new angle to this traditional story. Researchers found that dopamine doesn’t just record reward memories—it can also rewrite them and make them less valuable when we recall them. This happens especially when things around us change, like how we feel inside our bodies.
This means memory is more changing than we thought. Instead of dopamine just looking back at past events to learn, it might be actively changing memories all the time. This could mean that reward-based learning isn’t just about making connections, but also about rethinking and maybe even breaking those connections.
From a brain science view, this changes how we see dopamine. It’s not just about pleasure, but also important for managing emotions and being flexible in our behavior. We are always re-evaluating how much past rewards are worth based on new information. Dopamine, which we thought was just about forming habits, might also be key to breaking habits.
The Study Design: How Researchers Tested Their Idea
To test this idea, scientists designed a careful experiment with mice. They used classical conditioning, a proven way to study how we learn associations.
Phase 1: Making a Reward Memory
First, mice were trained to link a neutral sound (a tone) with a tasty reward: a sweet sugar drink. After repeating this many times, the mice started to show they were expecting a reward when they heard the sound alone. For example, they would go to the place where they usually got the treat when they heard the sound. This showed that they had learned to connect the sound with the reward memory.
Phase 2: Adding a Negative Feeling
This is where it got interesting. In the second part of the experiment, the mice heard the sound cue again, but this time they didn’t get a reward. Right after hearing the sound, they were made to feel a little sick using a safe method that causes temporary discomfort. This feeling of being unwell was like a negative internal state, like feeling nauseous.
It’s important to note that the mice didn’t actually eat the treat at this point. Instead, the sound cue brought back the memory of the reward, and this happened while they were feeling physically uncomfortable.
Phase 3: Checking Behavior Again
Later, when the mice felt normal again, researchers watched how they reacted to the original sound cue. The results were clear: they no longer went for the treat or acted excited about the cue like before. The experience that used to be rewarding was no longer appealing, even though the treat and the sound cue were still the same.
It was the feeling they had when they remembered the treat that made the difference. This is an example of memory changing as it is being remembered.
How Memory Recall Rewrites Emotions
This study highlights something important: recalling a memory isn’t just like replaying a recording. It’s a chance to change the memory, especially when our body or emotions are different from when we first experienced it.
When we recall memories, they can become flexible for a short time. This is called memory reconsolidation. The researchers showed that the emotional feeling of a memory can be changed, whether we know it or not, based on what’s happening when we remember it. If dopamine is active during this time—especially if our emotional state is different (like feeling sick)—then experiences that used to be rewarding can become unpleasant or just neutral.
This means the emotional feeling of a memory isn’t fixed forever. Instead, it’s constantly being adjusted based on what our body is telling us. Dopamine isn’t just a simple reward signal; it’s a flexible way to change our emotional learning and unlearning.
Dopamine Circuitry: How it Works at a Molecular Level
To understand how this process works on a molecular level, scientists used advanced tools. They used optogenetics, a method where light is used to control specific brain cells, to precisely control dopamine pathways.
Here’s how they studied dopamine’s effect on memory updating
- Finding the Neurons: First, scientists located the specific dopamine neurons that were active when the mice first learned the reward association.
- Turning Neurons On Artificially: Then, they used optogenetics to turn on these exact neurons while the mice were feeling sick, even if the sound cue wasn’t there.
- Turning Neurons Off: In another group, they temporarily turned off these dopamine neurons when the mice recalled the memory.
- Watching Behavior: Researchers carefully watched how these changes affected the mice’s behavior and memory related to the sound cue.
These precise actions had clear results. When dopamine neurons were turned on while the mice felt sick, the memory became even worse. The mice showed an even stronger dislike for the cue that used to be good. But when dopamine activity was blocked during memory recall, the memory didn’t become worse at all.
This clearly shows that dopamine is both needed and able to change the emotional feeling of a memory. It’s key in deciding whether the brain changes, keeps, or gets rid of the emotional value of an experience.
Computer Modeling: Predicting Behavior with Data
To make their findings stronger, the research team used computer modeling. They created models to simulate learning with changes in dopamine signals, using factors like internal states, memory recall, and emotional results.
The goal was to see if computer programs based on brain data could correctly predict the behavior changes seen in the mice. Amazingly, the models did work. They predicted that mice would want the reward less after having the memory-devaluation experience.
This match between computer data and real behavior is important. It suggests the findings are solid and can be repeated. More importantly, it shows that emotional learning and memory updating can be understood in a mathematical way. This could lead to new methods to find, track, and even treat mental health conditions in people using computer-based treatments.
Emotional and Behavioral Plasticity: The Brain’s Ability to Adapt
This study shows us something big about the brain: it’s always changing. It’s not just about storing information, but also about how it decides what information is emotionally important based on new experiences.
This ability to change, called emotional plasticity, shows that our feelings of joy, fear, desire, satisfaction, or disgust aren’t set in stone. They can change, constantly shaped by what’s happening around us and inside our bodies. This change goes from reward learning that first made us do something to later making us stop or avoid it.
This could explain why we might start to dislike a food we once loved after getting sick from it—even if we know it wasn’t really the food’s fault. Or why certain people, songs, or places lose their meaning when we experience them in a different emotional state.
Connecting the Dots: Dopamine, Addiction, and Treatment Possibilities
Now we get to perhaps the most important part for society: addiction treatment. Addiction isn’t just physical dependence—it’s also a cycle of strong emotional memories that drive people to do things they can’t stop. The dopamine system strengthens these behaviors not just when someone uses a substance, but also by making positive emotional memories linked to that experience stronger.
This research suggests that targeting those memories when dopamine is low or when someone feels bad could help weaken their hold. By combining treatments with the right timing of brain chemistry—like recalling memories during therapy when someone feels down or neutral—doctors could use dopamine’s role as a changing agent to help people recover.
Possible treatments could include
- Guided memory recall sessions along with things that reduce stress or make someone less hungry.
- Therapy that exposes people to triggers but is timed with internal states or emotional calmness.
- Medicines that change how dopamine reacts during memory recall phases.
Neuropsychiatric Implications: Beyond Addiction
There are many other uses beyond addiction. For example, in PTSD, fear memories are often too strong for the actual danger now. If these memories can be recalled in a safe, low-stress setting, changing dopamine levels might help reduce long-term emotional trauma. Early research on reducing fear supports this idea, but using it in treatment needs to be done carefully.
Similarly, for behaviors like hoarding, overeating, or gambling, where reward memories get “stuck” in cycles of wanting, changing those memories might be more helpful than just trying to stop the actions later. If dopamine helps us choose which memories are emotionally important and which to forget, it becomes a tool for specific treatments.
Study Limitations: Size and Animal Models
While these findings are interesting, we should be carefully hopeful. The study was done in mice, which, while similar to humans in some brain ways, don’t fully represent how complex human thinking, memory, or emotions are.
Also, the “reward” in this study—a sugary treat—is much simpler than the complex rewards or emotional triggers in human life. Future studies need to see if more complex or abstract memories can also be changed through dopamine-related recall.
Future Research: From Mice to People
Going forward, researchers are eager to use these findings in human studies. This includes studying how people behave when they recall specific memories in controlled emotional states.
Other future research areas include
- Studying what happens in the long run with repeated memory changes.
- Testing if positive change is also possible—can bad memories be “re-painted” in a good way through dopamine?
- Using brain scans to track dopamine activity during therapy.
- Looking at uses in education or workplaces to increase motivation.
Why This Matters: Changing How We See Ourselves
Dopamine’s changing role connects reward learning, memory, and emotional management. What started as a simple idea of dopamine as a pleasure chemical has grown into a bigger picture that affects habit making, value changes, and new treatments.
The implications are big. Families dealing with mental illness, therapists helping with trauma, teachers building resilience—all might one day use these ideas to help people change the emotional weight of their memories, not just relive them.
Turning Science into Well-Being: What You Can Do Now
While treatments are still being developed, people can start to think about this in their own lives. Think about habits you want to change in situations where the emotional reward isn’t there. Try mindfulness or body awareness exercises before thinking about a hard memory. Notice how your inner feelings affect certain flashbacks or choices.
We often say, “I wasn’t myself”—but science now shows that who “you” are depends on when, how, and in what emotional state you’re remembering. Understanding dopamine’s deeper role can help you change not just what you remember, but how strongly you feel about remembering it.
Final Thoughts: Relearning What Learning Means
This new brain research shows dopamine is more than just a reward chemical. It’s like a brain editor that guides how memories grow, change, and fade. From addiction to worry, daily habits to lifelong fears, we may be closer than ever to understanding how our brains constantly rewrite the meaning of our own stories.
And if memory itself can be changed, maybe we can be too.
Citation
- Fry, B. R., Russell, N., Fex, V., Mo, B., Pence, N., Beatty, J. A., Manfredsson, F. P., Toth, B. A., Burgess, C. R., Gershman, S., & Johnson, A. W. (2024). Devaluing memories of reward: a case for dopamine. Communications Biology. https://doi.org/10.1038/s42003-024-07440-7
